A lively community discussion has erupted on Facebook about the way in which the local member, Josh Matlow (Ward 22) and others have tweeted news on the case of Dennis Cibulka, 313 Manor Rd. Many people feel that “confidentiality” has somehow been breached. This is a common and humanitarian response to the distress felt by those who are caught up in public events. In the end, however, the story of 313 Manor Rd occurred out in the open and impacted many people. It is properly public and the dissemination of information is necessary for the common good. Keep in mind that it was the homeowner who resisted the city’s efforts to resolve the health and safety hazard in a less open and prolonged fashion. The case went to court, where public scrutiny is essential, so that the health department might enter. It will be argued that it is not possible to have a half open society. There is a thing called privacy, but there is an onus on the individual to see that his privacy is protected. Going to court in the face of common sense about public health is not helpful in ensuring privacy. We do not know if Mr. Cibulka resents the news coverage in any case. He has been interviewed by the media. He clearly felt strongly about his position and had, it is said, good counsel. See and participate in the debate
